The Gap Between Knowing and Changing

Clarity Needs Someone to Hold It

I want to ask you something that I think most men have a clear answer to, even if they’d rather not look at it directly.

Do you know what needs to change in your life right now?

Not in a vague, something feels off kind of way. More specifically than that. If you sat quietly for twenty minutes with no phone and no distraction, do you actually know?

In my experience, most men do. They have a very clear sense of the thing. The part of life that’s been running on autopilot too long, the conversation that keeps not happening, the version of themselves they’ve been meaning to get back to. The knowing is usually there. What’s much rarer is doing something with it.

One STORY

A few years ago I went through a year-long leadership programme, four seven-day retreats across twelve months.

The kind of work that gets into the places you’ve been avoiding...

After the first retreat I came home, put the key in the door, and fell into the hallway on my hands and knees. My now ex-wife was standing there looking at me and all I could say was, “I don’t know who I am anymore.”

Not because things had fallen apart. Because I’d finally been honest with myself about the gap between the version of me I’d been performing and the version that was actually there underneath it. The clarity was SO real, it was significant, and I had absolutely no idea what to do with it on my own.

What held me through that period wasn’t the retreat, as powerful as it was. It wasn’t even the therapy, though that helped. It was the people around me who were willing to sit in the mess with me without trying to tidy it up quickly. My mate Phil, who I do a daily voice note check-in with every morning. A few other men who knew how to listen without fixing. The men in my group who had seen me fall apart and didn’t run.

Clarity on its own has a surprisingly short shelf life. Something has to hold it in place while you figure out what to do with it. And in my experience that something is almost always another person.

The inner work is essential. But it was never meant to be done in isolation. Men have been sitting around fires together for hundreds of thousands of years for exactly this reason.

I think about that a lot when I work with men who have done something brave and honest, read a book that landed, come to a circle, sat with difficult questions about their life, and then gone back to everything unchanged. The insight stays for a while, then gets covered over by the noise of the following week, and six months later they’re roughly where they started. Not because the moment wasn’t real but because nothing around them changed to hold what they found.

One SHIFT

Here’s what I’ve noticed working with men over fifteen years. The gap between knowing and changing is almost never about intelligence or motivation or willpower.

It’s about the absence of a witness. When something shifts for a man and he takes it back into a life where nobody knows it shifted, the gravitational pull of the old patterns is enormous. But when he tells someone, when he brings another person into the room with him and says this is where I actually am, something in him becomes accountable to it in a way that thinking alone never achieves.

You don’t need a therapist for this, though therapy is valuable. You don’t need a coach, though that helps too. You need one person who knows what’s actually going on with you. Not the fine version. The real one. That’s it. One person who has been let into the actual texture of your life right now, the things you’re carrying, the things you’re uncertain about, the questions you haven’t answered yet.

That sounds simple and in some ways it is. But I meet men every week who don’t have that. Men who, if something went seriously wrong, genuinely don’t know who they’d call first. I think it’s one of the most important things a man in midlife can get right.

One Challenge

I invite you to do one thing with whatever has been sitting with you lately.

The thing you know about, the question that keeps surfacing, the part of life that needs attention you haven’t quite given it. I want you to say some version of it out loud to one person you trust.

It doesn’t need to be the whole thing or perfectly articulated. It can be as simple as: “I’ve been sitting with something lately and I haven’t quite figured out what to do with it.” That’s enough. You’re not looking for advice. You’re just bringing someone into the room with you, because that’s where things start to shift.

If you can’t think of who that person might be, that’s worth sitting with too. It’s one of the most important questions to ask yourself.

Beyond “I’m Fine”

If you’ve not yet been through the Beyond I’m Fine five-day email series, it’s worth your time. Five short emails, one a day, that ask some of the questions most men have been avoiding...

It’s been downloaded and helped over 1000 men.

Start Beyond I’m Fine — 5 Days To Clarity, a FREE gift from me.